BEYOND CAUSALITY:  A REINTERPRETATION OF HEGEL’S CONCEPT OF TAT IN THE QUESTION OF THE RESPONSIBILITY AND IMPUTATION

Battistoni, Giulia; Battistoni, Giulia

2/2017, [:it]dicembre[:en]December[:] ISBN: [:it]978-88-31928-35-9[:en]978-88-31928-32-8[:]pp. 82 - 99 DOI: 10.19280/P2017-2-005

Abstract

By reconceptualizing the Hegelian concept of Tat as it is suggested in different but noteworthy ways by the jurist Karl Larenz (1927) and the philosopher Mark Alznauer (2015), this paper aims to show that responsibility and imputation are in Hegel not limited to either a merely causal or merely subjective perspective of agency. The concept of End (Zweck), which is analyzed in the section “Teleology” of the Science of Logic, manifests itself as going beyond causal connection and allows Larenz to determine the teleological character of the imputation of the deed (Tat). Moreover, the normative standards which arerecognized by the members of a society as rational laws play an important role insofar as they provide a common yardstick by which to judge human agency within the social sphere. Starting from Hegel’s theory of action, Larenz and Alznauer have shown that it is possible to give account of the kinds of events that must be imputed to an agent, even if she did not intend or cause them.

Download this article Cite this article

MLA	Battistoni, Giulia . "BEYOND CAUSALITY: A REINTERPRETATION OF HEGEL’S CONCEPT OF TAT IN THE QUESTION OF THE RESPONSIBILITY AND IMPUTATION". Pólemos X. 2. (2017): 82-99 https://www.rivistapolemos.it/beyond-causality-a-reinterpretation-of-hegels-concept-of-tat-in-the-question-of-the-responsibility-and-imputation/?lang=en
APA	Battistoni, . (2017). "BEYOND CAUSALITY: A REINTERPRETATION OF HEGEL’S CONCEPT OF TAT IN THE QUESTION OF THE RESPONSIBILITY AND IMPUTATION". Pólemos X. (2). 82-99 https://www.rivistapolemos.it/beyond-causality-a-reinterpretation-of-hegels-concept-of-tat-in-the-question-of-the-responsibility-and-imputation/?lang=en
Chicago	Battistoni, Giulia . 2017. "BEYOND CAUSALITY: A REINTERPRETATION OF HEGEL’S CONCEPT OF TAT IN THE QUESTION OF THE RESPONSIBILITY AND IMPUTATION". Pólemos X (2). Donzelli Editore: 82-99. https://www.rivistapolemos.it/beyond-causality-a-reinterpretation-of-hegels-concept-of-tat-in-the-question-of-the-responsibility-and-imputation/?lang=en
RIS	Export a RIS file for Agaion, BibDesk, Biblioscape, Bibus, Bookends, Citavi, CiteULike, Connotea, Docear, EndNote, JabRef, KBibTeX, Mendeley, Papers,ProCite, Refbase, RefDB, Referencer, RefWorks, Reference Manager, Scholar’s Aid, SciRef, Sente, Wikindx, WizFolio, Zotero…
BibTeX	Export a BIB file for Bebop, BibSonomy, BibTeX, Jumper 2.0, Pybliographer, Qiqqa…

TY - JOUR
A1 - Battistoni, Giulia  
 
PY - 2017 
TI - BEYOND CAUSALITY:  A REINTERPRETATION OF HEGEL’S CONCEPT OF TAT IN THE QUESTION OF THE RESPONSIBILITY AND IMPUTATION 
JO - Plemos 
SN - [:it]978-88-31928-35-9[:en]978-88-31928-32-8[:]/2281-9517 
AB - By reconceptualizing the Hegelian concept of Tat as it is suggested in different but noteworthy ways by the jurist Karl Larenz (1927) and the philosopher Mark Alznauer (2015), this paper aims to show that responsibility and imputation are in Hegel not limited to either a merely causal or merely subjective perspective of agency. The concept of End (Zweck), which is analyzed in the section “Teleology” of the Science of Logic, manifests itself as going beyond causal connection and allows Larenz to determine the teleological character of the imputation of the deed (Tat). Moreover, the normative standards which arerecognized by the members of a society as rational laws play an important role insofar as they provide a common yardstick by which to judge human agency within the social sphere. Starting from Hegel’s theory of action, Larenz and Alznauer have shown that it is possible to give account of the kinds of events that must be imputed to an agent, even if she did not intend or cause them.  
SE - 2/2017 
DA - 2017 
KW - responsabilità
KW - fatto
KW - imputazione
KW - teoria dell’azione
KW - Tat
KW - imputation
KW - responsibility
KW - action theory
KW - Hegel   
UR - https://www.rivistapolemos.it/beyond-causality-a-reinterpretation-of-hegels-concept-of-tat-in-the-question-of-the-responsibility-and-imputation/?lang=en 
DO - 10.19280/P2017-2-005 
PB - Donzelli Editore
LA - en  
SP - 82 
EP - 99 
ER -

@article{1019280/P20172005,
author = {Giulia  Battistoni},
title = {BEYOND CAUSALITY:  A REINTERPRETATION OF HEGEL’S CONCEPT OF TAT IN THE QUESTION OF THE RESPONSIBILITY AND IMPUTATION},
publisher = {Donzelli Editore},
year = {2017},
ISBN = {[:it]978-88-31928-35-9[:en]978-88-31928-32-8[:]},
issn = {2281-9517},
abstract = {By reconceptualizing the Hegelian concept of Tat as it is suggested in different but noteworthy ways by the jurist Karl Larenz (1927) and the philosopher Mark Alznauer (2015), this paper aims to show that responsibility and imputation are in Hegel not limited to either a merely causal or merely subjective perspective of agency. The concept of End (Zweck), which is analyzed in the section “Teleology” of the Science of Logic, manifests itself as going beyond causal connection and allows Larenz to determine the teleological character of the imputation of the deed (Tat). Moreover, the normative standards which arerecognized by the members of a society as rational laws play an important role insofar as they provide a common yardstick by which to judge human agency within the social sphere. Starting from Hegel’s theory of action, Larenz and Alznauer have shown that it is possible to give account of the kinds of events that must be imputed to an agent, even if she did not intend or cause them.}
journal = {Pólemos},
number = {2/2017},
doi = {10.19280/P2017-2-005},
URL = {https://www.rivistapolemos.it/beyond-causality-a-reinterpretation-of-hegels-concept-of-tat-in-the-question-of-the-responsibility-and-imputation/?lang=en},
keywords = {responsabilità; fatto; imputazione; teoria dell’azione; Tat; imputation; responsibility; action theory; Hegel.},
pages = {82-99},
language = {en}
}

Keyword

responsabilità fatto imputazione teoria dell’azione Tat imputation responsibility action theory Hegel

Pólemos

Materials of philosophy and social criticism

Primary Menu

BEYOND CAUSALITY: A REINTERPRETATION OF HEGEL’S CONCEPT OF TAT IN THE QUESTION OF THE RESPONSIBILITY AND IMPUTATION

Abstract

Keyword

Archive

Keyword

Contacts

in the same issue

about the same topic